Sudden Oak Death (SOD) was first identified in the mid-1990s, when a large number of oaks and tanoaks began dying off in California’s coastal hardwood forests apparently victims of an then unknown disease. By the summer of 2000, the pathogen causing SOD was isolated, and was subsequently named Phytophthora ramorum. Since 2004, SOD has been recognized in 14 coastal California counties, from Monterey north to Humboldt, as well as in Curry County, Oregon. While the disease has continued to spread within the infested area, no new counties in either state have been found with the pathogen.
In the affected Pacific coastal region, SOD has killed well over a million trees. Half a million trees have been killed just in the most heavily infested California counties over a two-year period (2012-1013). Plants mortally affected by the pathogen include tanoak (Notholithocarpus densiflorus), coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia), California black oak (Q. kelloggii), canyon live oak (Q. chrysolepis), and Shreve's oak (Q. parvula var. shrevei). When plants are small, or in instances where there is a heavy inoculum load, rhododendron, camellia, madrone (Arbutus menziesii), evergreen huckleberry (Vaccinium ovatum), and other hosts may also succumb to the pathogen. In addition, several conifers have been identified as hosts, although the impact of the pathogen on them remains unclear. In the US, these include coastal redwood (Sequoia sempervirens), Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii), grand fir (Abies grandis), and Pacific yew (Taxus brevifolia). In the United Kingdom (UK), they include Japanese larch (Larix kaempferi) and western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla - native to North America). In all, nearly 130 plant species are currently recognized by the US as hosts of P. ramorum; however, as the list can change, it is important to reference the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection (APHIS) website http://www.aphis.usda.gov/plant_health/plant_pest_info/pram/downloads/pdf_files/usdaprlist.pdf for the most current information. Many hosts do not die if infected, but rather act as sources of inoculum. Of those hosts that support inoculum production, California bay laurel (Umbellularia californica) and tanoak are considered to be the driving force of pathogen distribution in California and Oregon forests, with spores readily building up on the leaves and twigs, and then dispersing into the local environment.
In California and Oregon, some of these species are the dominant hardwoods over large areas, growing in nearly pure stands. P. ramorum is now known to infect nearly all of the major trees species in California’s infested counties. At present, the pathogen is found in only about 10% of California’s forest area considered to be at risk. According to a model developed by Ross Meentemeyer (University of North Carolina, Charlotte), in the absence of any control efforts, the epidemic may increase ten-fold by 2030 along the coast, from the San Francisco Bay Area into Oregon.
The disease can affect even trees that are not highly vulnerable hosts. When SOD invades a tanoak-redwood forest, it not only kills the tanoaks - the principal hardwood /mast-bearing species in these forests. It also changes the fire dynamic in ways that damage the redwoods, also. The dead tanoaks provide more fuel for wildfires; the gaps created by their death also makes the forests dryer. Finally, flames can reach the forest canopy by traveling up the standing dead tanoaks. This means that redwood trees' crowns, which normally are out of reach of the fires, are scorched. The result is that the redwoods are killed at rates nearly four times those of un-infested forest plots.
In the United Kingdom, P. ramorum has been found in mature larch plantations, infecting shoots and foliage, producing wilted, withered shoot tips, blackened needles, and branch dieback. Since 2009, 8.5 million larch over nearly 22,000 acres have either been cut or are in the process of being felled in an effort to contain the pathogen’s spread. Understory beech, birch, oak, and western hemlock have all been found with bole cankers. Some of the confirmed sites have little or no rhododendron present. Prior to these findings in 2009, tree infection in the UK has only been identified in relatively close proximity to infected rhododendron.
Phytophthora ramorum is a non-native, invasive species in North America and Europe. It is believed that the pathogen was imported to both continents via the ornamental plant trade through several separate introductions from probably more than one unknown location. Through genotyping efforts, four clonal lineages have been identified – two in North America (NA1 and NA2) and two in the Europe (EU1 and EU2) – all of which likely diverged more than 100,000 years ago. At least five global migrations of the pathogen have occurred, with the NA1, NA2, and EU1 lineages being imported into North America, and the EU1 and EU2 lineage into Europe. It is believed that the US and Canada received the EU1 lineage unknowingly through importation from Europe. To date, the four lineages have not been found recombining in natural settings; however, there is still apprehension over their coexisting in one location at a given time, as a hybridized genotype could cause even more die-off and would further complicate suppression and containment efforts.
There is concern that P. ramorum could become established in eastern North America, causing significant damage if the pathogen were introduced to the natural environment in a location where host plants and climatic conditions were conducive to pathogen viability. Many tree and shrub species native to the East Coast are hosts of the pathogen, as demonstrated by laboratory studies or natural infection of the species in plantings in Europe. Species of concern include northern red oak (Quercus rubra), chestnut oak (Q. prinus), white oak (Q. alba), pin oak (Q. palustris), sugar maple (Acer saccharum), black walnut (Juglans nigra), and mountain laurel (Kalmia latifolia). Of most concern is northern red oak as it has been found naturally infected in Europe and is highly susceptible in laboratory studies. Northern red oak is an extremely valuable wildlife food source and valuable for timber and oak veneer. Chestnut oak is also a concern as it has been found to be a susceptible stem and foliar species based on inoculation studies. This species is a dominant tree in the Piedmont and mountain regions, and its acorns are an important food source for wildlife. National risk maps are available (http://www.suddenoakdeath.org/html/modeling_phytophthora_ramorum.html) based on both host presence and climatic variables favorable to the disease.
To determine pathogen viability in the eastern US, it is necessary to establish if there are host plants present that will support sufficient levels of pathogen sporulation. Research to date has found that mountain laurel may die too quickly once infected to support pathogen spread. While eastern rhododendrons have not yet been tested, rhododendrons are key sporulating hosts for the EU1 lineage of the pathogen in Europe. Tooley and Browning (2009) determined that a number of plants common in eastern deciduous forests are foliar hosts (hosts with a potential to support sporulation), including flowering dogwood (Cornus florida), sassafras (Sassafras albidium), black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia), black cherry (Prunus serotina); and two widespread invasive species, Japanese honeysuckle (Lonicera japonica) and multiflora rose (Rosa multiflora).
Disease management in the West
In 2001, Oregon forest pathologists detected P. ramorum in Curry County (southwest Oregon, just north of the California border). State and federal agencies there tried for a dozen years to eradicate outbreaks. As the pathogen is a water-loving organism, weather plays a vital role. In 2012, weather conditions fostered a rapid expansion and intensification of disease in Curry County, leading to expansion of the quarantined area to 264 km2. In the most heavily infested “generally infested area” (48 km2), treatment is no longer required. Eradication of P. ramorum is still required in high-priority sites chosen to try to slow the pathogen’s spread. In addition, federal agencies continue to treat infestations on federal land. Finally, officials are encouraging logging of tanoak to reduce inoculum levels.
To date, no cure for sudden oak death in forest ecosystems has been found. One treatment has been approved for use in California (phosphonate Agri-Fos®) on individual oaks and tanoaks; however, it is only effective in preventing healthy trees from becoming infected. While Agri-Fos® was originally only used to treat individual, high-value landscape trees, several studies are now under way regarding its potential for use to protect trees in forests.
Preventing spread of P. ramorum to uninfested areas of the country
Several common nursery trade species, such as rhododendron, camellia, viburnum, pieris, and kalmia, are also P. ramorum hosts. Given the relatively recent identification of the pathogen, the steep learning curve associated with its discovery, and the great variability of symptoms on hosts, it is not surprising that the pathogen has been unknowingly shipped on nursery stock. Awareness of this risk exploded in the spring of 2004 when officials discovered the disease on camellias at a large California nursery that shipped $30 million worth of plants interstate on an annual basis. By the end of 2004, 176 nurseries in 21 states had received infected plants, 125 of which were linked to the California supplier.
After some states took unilateral action, the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) imposed an Emergency Federal Order on the interstate movement of nursery stock, cut greens, and other host plant material from California, Oregon, and Washington (Code of Federal Regulations: 7 CFR 301.92 - http://www.gpoaccess.gov/cfr/retrieve.html - URL goes to CFR website where current regulations can be retrieved by entering 7 as title; 301 as part; 92 as section into correct boxes and leaving year as most recent). Federal regulations were first implemented in 2002; however, prior to 2004, they only included the 14 infested California counties and the infested area of Curry County, Oregon.
These regulations have substantially reduced the presence of P. ramorum on nursery stock; however, they have not successfully eliminated it. Between 2003 and 2011, 464 nurseries in 27 states had tested positive for the pathogen, the majority as a result of having received infected plants from wholesalers. In 2012, 21 nurseries were confirmed as having infected plants; in 2013, 16 nurseries.
A major concern is the continuing presence of nurseries that have been found to have P. ramorum-positive plants more than one year, despite having carried out the USDA APHIS Confirmed Nursery Protocol (http://www.aphis.usda.gov/plant_health/plant_pest_info/pram/downloads/pdf_files/CNPv8.0-Oct-08.pdf). In such instances, it is often not clear whether the infestation has persisted or has been re-introduced to the nursery from another location. Genetic testing for the pathogen lineage would help to distinguish between repeat nurseries and new introductions; however, such rigorous analysis is not required. The pathogen can persist in plant material, water, soil, and growing media, including on recycled pots.
Another concern is the extent to which P. ramorum can escape infested nurseries (or diseased nursery stock planted in yards or other places) and cause disease in native plants. In some cases, vegetation outside infested nurseries has been found infected. One case occurred in Washington in 2009, when infected salal (Gaultheria shallon) plants growing on a stream bank outside an infested nursery were P. ramorum-positive water from the infested nursery area ran off into a stand of native salal. The salal has since been removed, and plans are under way to pave over the area. This was the first documented incident of P. ramorum moving out of an infested nursery and causing disease outside the nursery. APHIS began requiring testing of water inside infested nurseries in 2005; however, only nursery water used for irrigation is required to be cleaned up if the pathogen is found. Other water found onsite can remain contaminated, regardless of its threat to plants and the surrounding landscape if a flood were to occur. P. ramorum has also escaped from some nurseries into streams or ponds in Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, North Carolina, and Texas. Whether the pathogen will spread further in these regions is not yet known.
The USDA Forest Service (FS) has been testing streams since 2006 as part of the P. ramorum of Forest Environments. In total, 320 unique watersheds have been surveyed. As of 2013, this survey has identified seven streams in Washington State, and 11 streams in the Southeast. Oregon and California operate their own, more extensive, stream survey programs. Oregon has never found P. ramorum in streams outside the Curry County outbreak area.
Nursery management practices are key to elimination of the pathogen in the ornamental nursery industry. There is agreement that the most effective program would rely on a critical control point strategy or systems-based approach using the best available science. In January 2014, APHIS issued a Federal Order that requires nurseries that test positive for P. ramorum to adopt APHIS-approved integrated management programs to address all the identified high-risk actions. For the first time, the agency will regulate based on testing of water, soil, and other potentially-infested articles in the nursery, not just the presence of diseased plants. [United States Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service. 2014. APHIS Revises Phytophthora ramorum Domestic Quarantine Regulatory Requirements for Certain Host Nurseries. January 10, 2014]
The European (EU1) and US lineages (NA1, NA2) of P. ramorum have different environmental and host preferences, and apparently different levels of virulence. The origin of the European strain, like the US strain, is from an unknown location; however, it is likely from a different source than the US source given the different lineage.
Before the pathogen was formally named, in Europe the pathogen was found on German nursery and landscape rhododendron plants in the mid-1990s. In 2004 it was found in nurseries in at least 11 European countries. By 2009, P. ramorum had been found in nurseries or gardens in 22 European countries, from Ireland and Norway to Poland and Serbia.
In autumn 2003, UK scientists detected the first cases of nearby trees becoming infected as a result of spores from outplanted nursery stock. By 2008, there were burgeoning reports of landscape outbreaks throughout Europe, with 14 countries affected; however, infected forest trees are still found only in the UK and Netherlands. Of the impacted European countries, the UK has had the greatest number of infestations, with more than 150 outbreaks in managed gardens, woodlands, or wild planting areas in England, Wales, and Scotland. Concern there over the health of ecologically valuable heathlands is great, as bilberry (Vaccinium myrtillus) is the dominant species, and it is highly vulnerable to the pathogen, as well as a good supporter of its sporulation. Four of the seven types of the world’s heathland occur in England, with the UK supporting approximately 75% of the total (global) upland habitat.
In spring 2009, the UK Government launched a 5-year program aimed at reducing P. ramorum and P. kernoviae inoculum to epidemiologically insignificant levels. Program components include removal of the principal sporulating host (the exotic plant Rhododendron ponticum) and the identification and control of any new outbreaks, helping to minimize the risk of further disease development or pathogen spread. P. ramorum and P. kernoviae research continues to improve understanding of the diseases they cause as well as to identify more effective control measures. To implement the 5-year program, £4 million was allocated for the first three years.
For more information on P. ramorum and Sudden Oak Death, go to the California Oak Mortality Task Force website at www.suddenoakdeath.org.
This write-up benefitted from significant input from Katie Palmieri of the California Oak Mortality Task Force.
European Union. 2009. Risk Analysis of Phytophthora ramorum, a Newly Recognised Pathogen Threat to Europe and the Cause of Sudden Oak Death in the USA. http://rapra.csl.gov.uk/.
Frankel, S.J., J.T. Kliejunas, and K.M. Palmieri, technical coordinators. 2008. Proceedings of the sudden oak death third science symposium. Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-GTR-214. Albany, CA: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station. 491 p. Available online at: http://www.fs.fed.us/psw/publications/documents/psw_gtr214/.
Frankel, S.J., J.T. Kliejunas, and K.M. Palmieri, technical coordinators. 2010. Proceedings of the sudden oak death fourth science symposium. Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-GTR-XXX. Albany, CA: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station. In press.
Goss, E.M.; Larsen, M.; Chastagner, G.A.; Givens, D.R.; and Grünwald, N.J. 2009. Population genetic analysis infers migration pathways of Phytophthora ramorum in US nurseries. PLoS Pathog 5(9): e1000583.
Hansen, E.M., A. Kanaskie, S. Prospero, M. McWilliams, E.M. Goheen, N. Osterbauer, P. Reeser, and W. Sutton. 2008. Epidemiology of Phytophthora ramorum Oregon tanoak forests. Can. J. For. Res. 38:1133-1143. DOI: 10.1139/X07-217.
Kliejunas, John T. 2007. Sudden Oak Death and Phytophthora ramorum: A Summary of the Literature. Albany, California. Pacific Southwest Research Station, Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture. http://www.suddenoakdeath.org/html/sod_literature_summary.html.
Mascheretti, S.; Croucher, P.J.P.; Kozanitas, M.; Baker, L.; and Garbelotto, M. 2009. Genetic epidemiology of the Sudden Oak Death pathogen Phytophthora ramorum in California. Molecular Ecology 18: 4577–4590.
Rizzo, D.M. and M. Garbelotto. 2003. Sudden oak death: endangering California and Oregon forest ecosystems. . Ecol. Environ. 1(5): 197-204.
Tooley, P. and Browning, M. 2009. to Phytophthora ramorum Inoculum Production Potential of Some Common Eastern Forest Understory Plant Species. Plant Disease 93:3 Pages 249-256.
Tooley, P. and Kyde, K. 2007. of Some Eastern Forest Species to Phytophthora ramorum. Plant Disease , 435–438.
Werres, S.; Marwitz, R.; Man Int Veld, W.A.; Cock, A.W.; Bonants, P.J.M.; De Weerdt, M.; Themann, K.; Ilieva, E.; and Baayen, R.P. 2001. Phytophthora ramorum sp. nov., a new pathogen on Rhododendron and Viburnum. Mycol. Re. 105: 1155-1165.